Why are brown and black communities disproportionately affected by COVID-19? Two task forces seek answers, solutions

5

Flint, MI—In response to the disproportionate effects of COVID-19 on black and Latinx communities, local community groups partnered to create The Greater Flint Coronavirus Taskforce on Racial Disparities.

“If you look at the zip code 48505 or actually the city of Flint proper and even some zip codes in Flint Township and Grand Blanc, [they] show an overwhelming, concentrated impact of COVID-19,” said Isaiah Oliver CEO of the Community Foundation of Greater Flint, which spearheaded the creation of the task force.

Michigan State University Division of Public Health, the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation, the City of Flint, Flint Genesee Chamber of Commerce, Hamilton Community Health Network and Shiloh Missionary Baptist Church, partnered with the CFGF to create the task force.

As soon as preliminary data from the CDC started being released, it became clear that COVID-19 is disproportionately affecting brown and black communities across the country. Flint is no exception. According to the Genesee County Health Department, as of press time, 43% of COVID-19 cases in the county have been from African Americans, 6% higher than the next highest group, caucasians. Percentage of deceased cases is also the highest within the African American community at 51%, 9% higher than the next highest group, again caucasians.

According to Oliver, the task force is focused on finding and securing equitable access to resource allocation for all community members. He said he also wants to prevent further disparities after the COVID-19 pandemic has ended, “Post COVID-19 care,” as he calls it. This will include providing wider access to testing, treatment and other related outcomes like food and work insecurity, Oliver said.

On Monday, April 20, the day before the local task force was announced, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer had shared the names of the members of a statewide taskforce with similar aims: the Michigan Coronavirus Task Force on Racial Disparities.

This brought some community leaders like Flint Board of Education member Blake Strozier, to question the lack of representation on the state’s task force and the necessity of a second local task force.

Upon its announcement, the state task force only had one Flint citizen on it, Associate Dean for Public Health Integration and Director of the Flint Center for Health Equity Solutions Dr. Debra Furr-Holden. Furr-Holden also serves as a member of the local task force.

A day later however, on Tuesday, April 21, Whitmer’s office announced Tonya Bailey, Ph.D., Chief Diversity Officer at Lansing Community College and Flint Township resident would also be joining the task force.

“Any representation is good representation,” said Strozier. “If we can be given a voice, that’s a positive in my thoughts.”

While his initial concerns about Flint representation on the state task force were soon addressed, Strozier said he thinks the formation of a local task force is superfluous. The real problem that needs to be addressed, he said, is the lack of transportation for community members to reach food distribution centers as well as hospitals.

“There is obviously a lack of recognition of the resources that exist in (these) communities, and the problem is not that we don’t have enough resources, but that we don’t have enough access to those resources,” Strozier said. “When are we going to stop the task forces and just provide access?” Strozier said.

Asa Zuccaro, executive director of the Latinx Technology and Community Center in Flint shared similar concerns about the task force’s effectiveness.

“I think the scope of just focusing on COVID-19 is way too small,” Zuccaro said, adding that he believes it shouldn’t take a worldwide pandemic to bring attention to underserved communities.

If that is what takes, he said, then he fears the solutions regarding these disparities will live only as long as the pandemic does.

“If the focus is on COVID-19, will the conversation have the ability to go where it needs to go … beyond just the immediate (situation) and go into depth on why communities of color face disparities?” Zuccaro said.

According to Zuccaro, similar attempts were made to address how the Flint Water Crisis had affected minority communities, most of them, he said, to no avail.

“What does that even mean?” he said, regarding promises of support from the local task force. “Can I request gloves and masks from the Community Foundation to pass out to residents?” he asked. “So I mean, what is it?”

Others, like Flint Mayor Sheldon Neely, are more optimistic about the task force’s formation.

“My hope and my greater wish for this task force is to put out a report for something we already know, for something that is already currently obvious throughout our state and our county and also our country,” he said. “The disparity between people of color and people not of color is a large gap in this pandemic, that has happened to reveal itself in the worst type of way.”

Though not directly related to the task force, Neely said he wants to see the causes for these disparities pinpointed and accounted for. “We have other compromising health issues that puts us more at risk than others. Even our environment many times.” Neely said. According to him, the task force will “look at issues of conditions and densely populated areas … It’s going to even go as far as talking about infant mortality.”

In addition, Neely sees the information the Greater Flint Coronavirus Taskforce on Racial Disparities will gather as future examples of the effects pandemics like COVID-19 can have on underserved communities. “at some point in the far reaches of this,” he said, “they’re going to be able to talk about this thing that is not natural and becoming moreover a genocide of types when we look at the disparities and what is the byproduct of the disparities.”

 

5 Comments
  1. Holly says

    There are more black people that live in Flint than white people. The numbers reflect the population of our city.

  2. Holly says

    The city is 53 percent black and 38 precent white so it makes since that blacks make up 43 percent of cases n whites 38 percent what should be looked into and studied is why 60 of the cases are female but make up 40percent of deaths while males make up only 40 percent of cases and 60 percent deaths. Was this virus being studied by China to fix their aging prodomently male population. China has tried several things over the years like making it illegal to have a girl had to get abortion if pregnant with as girl for many years. It seems like the disease kills elderly n men at a much higher rate than any other demographic.

  3. Jason Boisclair says

    This might not be uncommon, but this is my experience owning my home in Flint, MI and the people I have interacted with day to day.
    It wasn’t until Easter weekend that my friends and acquaintances actually took this seriously. I had more than one friend try to convince me that it was 5G towers awakening the virus. The weeks before this they truly thought it was a white folks disease and they weren’t worried about it.

    One friend doesn’t know how to read, so he goes by Facebook uploads from weirdos spreading ridiculous and dangerous rumours.

    Of course this might be a normal thing that everybody ran into with their friends which would make my point mute, but I heard this and continue to hear this from my non-white friends from the inner city. That is a failure of leadership whether from the president or more importantly the local community leaders!

  4. Latonya says

    It because I think air planes spread something in the air at weird hours of the night when we are in the house I stay right where they fly into the airport that only reason the
    black community are getting more effected than other communities
    the polite whistle blower told what
    they were doing and on top of that he wants to have a air show on July 4 for the front line that’s another lie that why he said when it come back in the fall it will only in small patches or something like that how would he know unless he’s doing it how else would he know it

  5. Rosa says

    I’m sure part of it is because they can’t seem to follow the social distancing also. They still hang out in large groups smoking blunts after each other and drinking after each other like it’s no big deal.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.